Where can I buy cheap ticket resellers?

My favorite band, which pretty much never tours, are playing at a very small venue in OC and their tickets were only $35. They went on sale at noon on Ticketweb, I was in the "waiting room" for ticket purchase and at 12:00 they were all sold out. I've checked ticket resellers such as Stubhub, Ticketmaster, FinallyItsYours, and Lucky Duck Tickets, and all of the ticket resellers are anywhere from $160 to $900 per ticket! Where can I find tickets at least somewhat near the face value price? Do you reccommend waiting a certain time before the concert date to look for tickets? (P.S. The date of the concert is December 9th). I am DESPERATE for these tickets, but not desperate enough to pay 100 bucks a pop. All suggestions are appreciated, thanks!